The passage of Proposition 1 and the setback for same sex marriage in Maine has provoked an important conclusion for many LGBT activists and allies: the movement is at a turning point where national action for LGBT equality is the order of the day. The absurdity of watching states adopt and recognize same sex marriage, only to have these gains erased by popular referendum – as if fundamental civil rights for a minority could be voted away by the majority – is having a transformative effect on consciousness. The dozens of struggles being waged at the local level around the country, and especially the fight over same sex marriage rights, has made the formerly impossible appear not only possible but necessary.
This change in consciousness within one important social movement also reflects a breakthrough in a broader sense as well, and it is no coincidence that it comes as Americans are also struggling with the transformation of the national health care system. In the 1980’s, the so-called Reagan Revolution opened an all-out attack on the rights of working and oppressed people and in general on the gains of the 60’s and 70’s. As this reactionary trend gained momentum, social movements for change became more and more a rearguard action, defending earlier gains on a state by state and community by community basis. Victories, too, tended to be local.
Despite changes in administrations from Republican to Democrat and back again, for more than three decades the progressive movements were in retreat both practically and psychologically. National campaigns such as the anti-war movement seemed to have little or no impact even when they successfully mobilized hundreds of thousands of people. For many of us, the United States looked more and more like a patchwork of regions and states. While the LGBT movement might win same sex marriage in Massachusetts, Kansas politicians were busy trying to keep the teaching of evolution out of public schools. New Haven, Connecticut might become a sanctuary city for undocumented immigrants but in Jena, Louisiana, a local district attorney was railroading African-American youth into lengthy jail sentences for a schoolyard fight.
In such a climate it is not too surprising that for many activists focusing energy making or defending local gains became not only a necessity but a virtue. . . and even a fetish. We have seen community non-profits mobilize militantly to challenge poverty and racism to effect neighborhood change while deliberately stifling any discussion of the broader government policies that created the problem. We have seen activists seemingly unable to grasp the concept of national solutions – single payer national health care, nationalization of the failing auto industry, a national moratorium on bankruptcies and home foreclosures – because of what is now a deeply bred fear of big government that rivals that of many conservatives. And the despair many of us feel over the successful attacks on reproductive rights of women in some right-wing dominated states has astonishingly not galvanized into a consensus that abortion rights must be protected at the federal level.
The emergence of the discussions about national health care reform and also, increasingly, about federal recognition of LGBT rights are reviving a long-discarded idea that progressive social change should not be limited to the places where progressives can guarantee a majority. And why should it? Social movements rarely mobilize the majority of the population or wait for a national consensus to make their demands heard. If there is a discussion and debate that is much-needed on the left in the U.S., it is this one: as the internet supposedly makes our world smaller, have we abandoned the idea of national social change?
Filed under: Community organizing, Fighting oppression




This meeting is intended as a conversation with Larry and local activists about the development of the Bail Out the People Movement nationally, the economic crisis, and the tasks ahead. The meeting will be held at the Hartford Metropolitan Community Church, 155 Wyllys Street, Hartford.



Recent Comments